## A A. Before the hold
Change: none
Caught by: -
Expected exit 0, got 0
$ node hold-verify.mjs --bundle bundle.jsonl --memory memory.jsonl --witness-key Gk_7mKVttcrtsSt9bly0UmYygEo0Na8xCJTgYwARr0g --recorder recorder.jsonl
Exit 0: record holds.

session_ref | start (witness) | release (witness) | release (RFC 3161) | reason | holds in force | covered | export
kjjuzxe475sm2wi4qaihrfw63i | 2026-10-28T05:37:48.544Z | 2026-10-28T05:38:36.258Z | 2026-10-28T05:38:36.000Z | ephemeral_stop | none | no | no

Released before hold zbfvpx6plkenfrqqomcytr3kwy was sealed: release witnessed 2026-10-28T05:38:36.258Z; hold sealed 2026-10-28T05:58:39.622Z.


## B B. Under the hold, preserved
Change: none
Caught by: -
Expected exit 0, got 0
$ node hold-verify.mjs --bundle bundle.jsonl --memory memory.jsonl --witness-key Gk_7mKVttcrtsSt9bly0UmYygEo0Na8xCJTgYwARr0g --export export
Exit 0: record holds.

session_ref | start (witness) | release (witness) | release (RFC 3161) | reason | holds in force | covered | export
43ij2nsckyha4zelnfbzznw5bu | 2026-10-28T06:06:34.772Z | 2026-10-28T06:07:22.796Z | 2026-10-28T06:07:22.000Z | pod_deleted | zbfvpx6plkenfrqqomcytr3kwy | yes | yes

Released while hold zbfvpx6plkenfrqqomcytr3kwy was in force; preservation export a8dd7abaf271f7b5311812ba520a94a96f61ff68aee891f8a4d7158dec3d1933 recorded.


## C C. Under the hold, not preserved
Change: none
Caught by: -
Expected exit 4, got 4
$ node hold-verify.mjs --bundle bundle.jsonl --memory memory.jsonl --witness-key Gk_7mKVttcrtsSt9bly0UmYygEo0Na8xCJTgYwARr0g
Exit 4: record holds, with gaps.

session_ref | start (witness) | release (witness) | release (RFC 3161) | reason | holds in force | covered | export
6jmhxsh3rwfubpxo6ixkxdu5om | 2026-10-28T06:07:29.156Z | 2026-10-28T06:08:15.211Z | 2026-10-28T06:08:15.000Z | pod_deleted | zbfvpx6plkenfrqqomcytr3kwy | yes | no

Released while hold zbfvpx6plkenfrqqomcytr3kwy was in force; no preservation export recorded.

Findings:
  R4 gap: session 6jmhxsh3rwfubpxo6ixkxdu5om was released while covered, with no preservation export recorded


## D D. Witness outage
Change: none
Caught by: -
Expected exit 4, got 4
$ node hold-verify.mjs --bundle bundle.jsonl --memory memory.jsonl --witness-key Gk_7mKVttcrtsSt9bly0UmYygEo0Na8xCJTgYwARr0g --recorder recorder.jsonl
Exit 4: record holds, with gaps.

session_ref | start (witness) | release (witness) | release (RFC 3161) | reason | holds in force | covered | export
s2fbtpjhmttiy7mosos57d5wmi | 2026-10-28T05:38:40.239Z | 2026-10-28T05:41:49.180Z | 2026-10-28T05:41:49.000Z | ephemeral_stop | none | no | no


Findings:
  W1 gap: the Hive Recorder could not reach the witness for line 8 (timeout)
  W1 gap: the Hive Recorder could not reach the witness for line 11 (timeout)
  W1 gap: the Hive Recorder could not reach the witness for line 14 (timeout)
  W1 gap: the Hive Recorder could not reach the witness for line 17 (timeout)
  W1 gap: the Hive Recorder could not reach the witness for line 20 (timeout)
  W1 gap: the Hive Recorder could not reach the witness for line 23 (timeout)
  W1 gap: the Hive Recorder could not reach the witness for line 26 (timeout)


## C-abandoned Session with no release (for case 9)
Change: none
Caught by: -
Expected exit 4, got 4
$ node hold-verify.mjs --bundle bundle.jsonl --memory memory.jsonl --witness-key Gk_7mKVttcrtsSt9bly0UmYygEo0Na8xCJTgYwARr0g
Exit 4: record holds, with gaps.

session_ref | start (witness) | release (witness) | release (RFC 3161) | reason | holds in force | covered | export
h2gi5jub7kus4my6wmfhfmathq | 2026-10-28T06:08:28.244Z | - | - | - | none | no | no

No release recorded; witness flagged the session at 2026-10-28T06:10:25.968Z.

Findings:
  R1 gap: no release recorded for session h2gi5jub7kus4my6wmfhfmathq; the witness flagged it at 2026-10-28T06:10:25.968Z


## 01 Break it 1
Change: Move session C's release time earlier than the hold, re-sign with the deleter keys
Caught by: Witness time and DigiCert token on the release
Expected exit 1, got 1
$ node hold-verify.mjs --bundle bundle.jsonl --memory memory.jsonl --witness-key Gk_7mKVttcrtsSt9bly0UmYygEo0Na8xCJTgYwARr0g
Exit 1: record changed.

session_ref | start (witness) | release (witness) | release (RFC 3161) | reason | holds in force | covered | export
6jmhxsh3rwfubpxo6ixkxdu5om | 2026-10-28T06:07:29.156Z | - | - | - | none | no | no


Findings:
  R2 changed: the release of session 6jmhxsh3rwfubpxo6ixkxdu5om was changed after the witness saw it
  R1 changed: the witness remembers a release of session 6jmhxsh3rwfubpxo6ixkxdu5om at 2026-10-28T06:08:15.211Z, and it was not handed over
  R1 gap: no release recorded for session 6jmhxsh3rwfubpxo6ixkxdu5om, and no witness flag yet


## 02 Break it 2
Change: Delete session C's release, re-sign the bundle
Caught by: R1 plus witness memory of the release statement
Expected exit 1, got 1
$ node hold-verify.mjs --bundle bundle.jsonl --memory memory.jsonl --witness-key Gk_7mKVttcrtsSt9bly0UmYygEo0Na8xCJTgYwARr0g
Exit 1: record changed.

session_ref | start (witness) | release (witness) | release (RFC 3161) | reason | holds in force | covered | export
6jmhxsh3rwfubpxo6ixkxdu5om | 2026-10-28T06:07:29.156Z | - | - | - | none | no | no


Findings:
  R1 changed: the witness remembers a release of session 6jmhxsh3rwfubpxo6ixkxdu5om at 2026-10-28T06:08:15.211Z, and it was not handed over
  R1 gap: no release recorded for session 6jmhxsh3rwfubpxo6ixkxdu5om, and no witness flag yet


## 03 Break it 3
Change: Swap session B's export hash for another archive
Caught by: R5 with --export
Expected exit 1, got 1
$ node hold-verify.mjs --bundle bundle.jsonl --memory memory.jsonl --witness-key Gk_7mKVttcrtsSt9bly0UmYygEo0Na8xCJTgYwARr0g --export export
Exit 1: record changed.

session_ref | start (witness) | release (witness) | release (RFC 3161) | reason | holds in force | covered | export
43ij2nsckyha4zelnfbzznw5bu | 2026-10-28T06:06:34.772Z | 2026-10-28T06:07:22.796Z | 2026-10-28T06:07:22.000Z | pod_deleted | zbfvpx6plkenfrqqomcytr3kwy | yes | yes

Released while hold zbfvpx6plkenfrqqomcytr3kwy was in force; preservation export a8dd7abaf271f7b5311812ba520a94a96f61ff68aee891f8a4d7158dec3d1933 recorded.

Findings:
  R5 changed: the export for session 43ij2nsckyha4zelnfbzznw5bu does not match the export hash on its release


## 04 Break it 4
Change: Add a hold signed by an unregistered key
Caught by: H1
Expected exit 1, got 1
$ node hold-verify.mjs --bundle bundle.jsonl --memory memory.jsonl --witness-key Gk_7mKVttcrtsSt9bly0UmYygEo0Na8xCJTgYwARr0g
Exit 1: record changed.

session_ref | start (witness) | release (witness) | release (RFC 3161) | reason | holds in force | covered | export
kjjuzxe475sm2wi4qaihrfw63i | 2026-10-28T05:37:48.544Z | 2026-10-28T05:38:36.258Z | 2026-10-28T05:38:36.000Z | ephemeral_stop | none | no | no

Released before hold zbfvpx6plkenfrqqomcytr3kwy was sealed: release witnessed 2026-10-28T05:38:36.258Z; hold sealed 2026-10-28T05:58:39.622Z.

Findings:
  H1 changed: hold tbyh6vbf5vyfqtw3ejyhh7o5w4 is not signed by a hold key registered to this tenant


## 05 Break it 5
Change: Backdate a hold's issued_at to before session A
Caught by: H2: witness time and DigiCert token disagree with the claim
Expected exit 1, got 1
$ node hold-verify.mjs --bundle bundle.jsonl --memory memory.jsonl --witness-key Gk_7mKVttcrtsSt9bly0UmYygEo0Na8xCJTgYwARr0g
Exit 1: record changed.

session_ref | start (witness) | release (witness) | release (RFC 3161) | reason | holds in force | covered | export
kjjuzxe475sm2wi4qaihrfw63i | 2026-10-28T05:37:48.544Z | 2026-10-28T05:38:36.258Z | 2026-10-28T05:38:36.000Z | ephemeral_stop | none | no | no


Findings:
  H2 changed: hold zbfvpx6plkenfrqqomcytr3kwy has no witness statement naming its hash
  H3 changed: the witness remembers hold zbfvpx6plkenfrqqomcytr3kwy, and it was not handed over


## 06 Break it 6
Change: Hand the verifier the bundle without hold H-A
Caught by: H3 with --ask-witness
Expected exit 1, got 1
$ node hold-verify.mjs --bundle bundle.jsonl --memory memory.jsonl --witness-key Gk_7mKVttcrtsSt9bly0UmYygEo0Na8xCJTgYwARr0g
Exit 1: record changed.

session_ref | start (witness) | release (witness) | release (RFC 3161) | reason | holds in force | covered | export
43ij2nsckyha4zelnfbzznw5bu | 2026-10-28T06:06:34.772Z | 2026-10-28T06:07:22.796Z | 2026-10-28T06:07:22.000Z | pod_deleted | zbfvpx6plkenfrqqomcytr3kwy | no | yes


Findings:
  H3 changed: the witness remembers hold zbfvpx6plkenfrqqomcytr3kwy, and it was not handed over
  R3 reported: the release of session 43ij2nsckyha4zelnfbzznw5bu lists holds the rule does not give at its witness time: zbfvpx6plkenfrqqomcytr3kwy


## 07 Break it 7
Change: Change session C's labels so the hold no longer covers it
Caught by: Session signature and witness session statement
Expected exit 1, got 1
$ node hold-verify.mjs --bundle bundle.jsonl --memory memory.jsonl --witness-key Gk_7mKVttcrtsSt9bly0UmYygEo0Na8xCJTgYwARr0g
Exit 1: record changed.

session_ref | start (witness) | release (witness) | release (RFC 3161) | reason | holds in force | covered | export
6jmhxsh3rwfubpxo6ixkxdu5om | - | - | - | - | none | no | no


Findings:
  S1 changed: session 6jmhxsh3rwfubpxo6ixkxdu5om was changed after the witness saw it


## 08 Break it 8
Change: Paste session B's release into session C
Caught by: Session ref in the release and the witness statement
Expected exit 1, got 1
$ node hold-verify.mjs --bundle bundle.jsonl --memory memory.jsonl --witness-key Gk_7mKVttcrtsSt9bly0UmYygEo0Na8xCJTgYwARr0g
Exit 1: record changed.

session_ref | start (witness) | release (witness) | release (RFC 3161) | reason | holds in force | covered | export
6jmhxsh3rwfubpxo6ixkxdu5om | 2026-10-28T06:07:29.156Z | - | - | - | none | no | no


Findings:
  R2 changed: the release of session 6jmhxsh3rwfubpxo6ixkxdu5om was changed after the witness saw it
  R1 changed: the witness remembers a release of session 6jmhxsh3rwfubpxo6ixkxdu5om at 2026-10-28T06:08:15.211Z, and it was not handed over
  R1 gap: no release recorded for session 6jmhxsh3rwfubpxo6ixkxdu5om, and no witness flag yet


## 09 Break it 9
Change: Drop session C's release entirely and never send one
Caught by: R1 plus witness release.missing after grace (60 second grace in the demo tenant)
Expected exit 4, got 4
$ node hold-verify.mjs --bundle bundle.jsonl --memory memory.jsonl --witness-key Gk_7mKVttcrtsSt9bly0UmYygEo0Na8xCJTgYwARr0g
Exit 4: record holds, with gaps.

session_ref | start (witness) | release (witness) | release (RFC 3161) | reason | holds in force | covered | export
h2gi5jub7kus4my6wmfhfmathq | 2026-10-28T06:08:28.244Z | - | - | - | none | no | no

No release recorded; witness flagged the session at 2026-10-28T06:10:25.968Z.

Findings:
  R1 gap: no release recorded for session h2gi5jub7kus4my6wmfhfmathq; the witness flagged it at 2026-10-28T06:10:25.968Z


## 10 Break it 10
Change: Remove the witness.missing statements from session D
Caught by: Hash links and Recorder line chain
Expected exit 1, got 1
$ node hold-verify.mjs --bundle bundle.jsonl --memory memory.jsonl --witness-key Gk_7mKVttcrtsSt9bly0UmYygEo0Na8xCJTgYwARr0g --recorder recorder.jsonl
Exit 1: record changed.

session_ref | start (witness) | release (witness) | release (RFC 3161) | reason | holds in force | covered | export
s2fbtpjhmttiy7mosos57d5wmi | 2026-10-28T05:38:40.239Z | 2026-10-28T05:41:49.180Z | 2026-10-28T05:41:49.000Z | ephemeral_stop | none | no | no


Findings:
  L1 changed: the Hive Recorder record linked to session s2fbtpjhmttiy7mosos57d5wmi fails its own check at CHAIN_ORDER: expected seq 9, found 10


## 11 Break it 11
Change: Rebuild session C from scratch under a new session ref, with an export
Caught by: Witness has no session statement for the new ref; the original ref's statements still show the real release
Expected exit 1, got 1
$ node hold-verify.mjs --bundle bundle.jsonl --memory memory.jsonl --witness-key Gk_7mKVttcrtsSt9bly0UmYygEo0Na8xCJTgYwARr0g
Exit 1: record changed.

session_ref | start (witness) | release (witness) | release (RFC 3161) | reason | holds in force | covered | export
vqtf62lmrwdjsmjmhlgbxhpivu | - | - | - | - | none | no | no


Findings:
  S1 changed: session vqtf62lmrwdjsmjmhlgbxhpivu has no witness session statement


## 12 Break it 12
Change: Present a different scope for hold H-A than the witness remembers
Caught by: H3 split-view check against witness memory
Expected exit 1, got 1
$ node hold-verify.mjs --bundle bundle.jsonl --memory memory.jsonl --witness-key Gk_7mKVttcrtsSt9bly0UmYygEo0Na8xCJTgYwARr0g
Exit 1: record changed.

session_ref | start (witness) | release (witness) | release (RFC 3161) | reason | holds in force | covered | export
43ij2nsckyha4zelnfbzznw5bu | 2026-10-28T06:06:34.772Z | 2026-10-28T06:07:22.796Z | 2026-10-28T06:07:22.000Z | pod_deleted | zbfvpx6plkenfrqqomcytr3kwy | no | yes


Findings:
  H2 changed: hold zbfvpx6plkenfrqqomcytr3kwy has no witness statement naming its hash
  H3 changed: the witness remembers hold zbfvpx6plkenfrqqomcytr3kwy, and it was not handed over
  R3 reported: the release of session 43ij2nsckyha4zelnfbzznw5bu lists holds the rule does not give at its witness time: zbfvpx6plkenfrqqomcytr3kwy
