Patent pending · Filed July 31, 2026

Multi-Source Divergence Detection

Multi-Source Divergence Detection (MSDD) binds what a provider asserts and what is separately observed into the same structure, without merging them into a single reconciled value.

Signing a relayed claim does not upgrade it. It produces a signed relayed claim. MSDD keeps the two kinds of evidence apart on purpose, so a verifier can see that they disagree, and can see it without access to the execution environment and without a trusted execution environment.

A signature does not make a claim true

Most attestation collapses everything into one field. The provider says which model served the request, that string gets signed, and the signature makes it look settled. All the signature proves is that the provider said it.

Relayed values

Model identity, build version, and configuration usually arrive as provider assertions. Nothing outside the provider corroborates them.

Premature merge

When asserted and observed values are reconciled into one number before signing, the disagreement is destroyed at exactly the moment it becomes interesting.

The hardware answer is narrow

A trusted execution environment can raise the evidentiary grade, but it requires specific silicon, specific attestation profiles, and provider cooperation. Most inference does not run that way.

How MSDD works

Two sources, carried side by side, bound to the same response, never averaged.

1

Record what was asserted

The provider's own statement is captured as an assertion and labelled as one. Its evidentiary basis travels with it, so nobody downstream mistakes a relayed value for a witnessed one.

2

Record what was separately observed

A second value is separately observed outside the provider's own reporting path. It comes from a different source than the assertion, which is the entire reason it has corroborating value.

3

Bind without merging

Both are bound into signed or linked structures covering the same response content. They remain separately addressable. A verifier reads both and compares them.

No trusted execution environment is required. Divergence is detected from the structure of the evidence rather than from a hardware root. A verifier needs the signed or linked structures. It does not need access to the execution environment, the provider's infrastructure, or an enclave attestation profile.

What a verifier reads

The output is not a verdict. It is a comparison that a third party can perform themselves and reach the same result.

StateWhat it meansWhat it does not mean
AgreementThe asserted value and the separately observed value line up for this response.It does not prove the assertion is true. It shows two sources are consistent.
DivergenceThe two sources disagree for this response, and the disagreement is bound to specific content.It does not by itself identify the cause, which may be substitution, misconfiguration, or a reporting error.
Single source onlyOnly an assertion is available and no separate observation was bound.It is not a failure. It is an honest statement that corroboration is absent.

Recording which values are witnessed and which are relayed, per field, inside the signature, is the design. Detectability after the fact is the guarantee that MSDD offers.

What this establishes

Established
  • Both values stay separately addressable. The assertion and the separate observation can each be read back on their own terms.
  • The comparison is reproducible. A third party working from the same signed or linked structures reaches the same result.
  • Both values are bound to one response. The evidence attaches to specific content rather than to a run in general.
  • Absence of corroboration is recorded. A single-source record says so on its face.
Not claimed
  • MSDD does not merge the two values. No reconciled figure is produced, and neither value is averaged into the other.
  • It does not decide which value is true. It establishes whether the two agree. Identifying the cause of a disagreement is a separate question.
  • It does not require a trusted execution environment. Verification needs the signed or linked structures, and no access to the provider's execution environment.

Where it sits

MSDD is one of four families filed on July 31, 2026, alongside Foretoken™, Stipryn™, and Bonded Performance Attestation (BPA). It is the route to raising the evidentiary grade of a provider-reported field without hardware attestation underneath it.

Foretoken

Commits to a streamed run before the first token and seals it at the close. Read

Stipryn

Fixes the required proof level before a request is transmitted. Read

MSDD

Binds asserted and separately observed values without merging them.

BPA

Binds a declared performance budget and the actual distribution to the same response. Read

MSDD in Hive Proof Architecture →

Run a receipt today

This is filed work and is not yet a public endpoint. The receipt discipline underneath it is live now: canonicalize, hash, sign, verify, and check it yourself in the browser.

Multi-Source Divergence Detection (MSDD). Patent pending, filed July 31, 2026. Binds provider-asserted and separately observed values without merging them, detectable by a verifier without a trusted execution environment. Hive Civilization Inc.

Private by design. Hive does not store your prompts. Every request is already receipted by a one-way SHA-256 fingerprint, not the words. Proof, not surveillance.